Screen Time and Language Development
Electronic devices cannot mediate for your child in a world that requires human interaction for wholeness of body, soul, and spirit.
Electronic devices cannot mediate for your child in a world that requires human interaction for wholeness of body, soul, and spirit.
I remember how annoying my kids from two- to five-years old were. Once they learned the word why?, it seemed like it was the only word they knew. However, their desire was to know and learn about life and the world around them – they were curious about everything! It is part of being human – being made in the Image of God. Only God’s Image Bearers ask why? – no other created living thing on earth asks why?! Asking why? helps them make sense of their being. The parent, grandparent, or teacher should foster questions and help generate answers by becoming a mediator between what the child observes and his understanding of it. The why? is a mark of being curious and the child needs caring individuals, NOT an electronic device, to foster his curiosity. Curiosity is the strong desire to know and to learn. Without curiosity, individuals look at their world with apathy and boredom rather than desiring to interact with the beauty in a created world and to relate to God’s Image Bearers.
A study published by the journal Neuron shows that curiosity also improves learning and memory. The study found that curiosity releases dopamine, a chemical associated with motivation that is more powerful than any A+ could be at the end of the day. Since God created us to be curious, it is only natural that He created an internal mechanism to help us be a curious Image Bearer.
The figure below was published in a controlled study published by Twenge and Campbell in December, 2018 journal, Preventative Medicine Reports. It portrays the percent of children by age and level of screen time who were not curious or interested in learning new things The graph depicts the findings that the higher the level of electronic device use, the less curious the child is. One can see that as the level of screen time goes up, the desire to know and learn goes down.
My explanation for these results bear the idea that: With eyes on electronics, the child doesn’t notice the flowers that are in bloom and ask why they are so beautiful. He doesn’t notice that a usually happy sibling is crying and ask why? and learn how to comfort them. Noticing, wanting to know more about, and understanding God’s creation is the mark of an intelligent human being and can and should be fostered by parents who encourage an attitude of curiosity in their children.
However, when using electronics, things move so quickly that the child does not have time to think how or why something happens and ask question. It is put into the short term memory; since the mind holds about seven (plus or minus 2) items for around 30 seconds without any rehearsal or reviewing, the data is coming in too fast to rehearse or review it. The device cannot ask questions because it does not help the child stop to mediate learning –that is, pay attention to what is important, ask questions about it, respond to misconceptions, and check to see if what is stored in the brain. Electronics cannot keep a child from developing faulty assumption or acquire moral character. With electronics, the brain learns to respond – not to think – not to ask why? or what?.
To think is to be curious and seek answers. Thinking is having ideas and resolving issues in the mind. Curiosity caused Moses to approach the burning bush, Einstein to come up with the theory of relativity, and NASA to solve problems of man venturing into space.
An electronic device will not give individuals the desire to seek Truth by asking questions like why?. When Christians are curious, they grow in knowledge and their ability to rightly discern situations (Hebrews 5:12-14).
“The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing…. Never lose a holy curiosity.”
Albert Einstein
A holy curiosity deepens our faith. Curious Christians display the qualities of hope expressed in their eagerness to learn and obey God and see Him work in their lives and in the world. The human mediator is the key to a healthy curious mind and produces an environment where Christian children can grow in knowledge and ability to rightly discuss situations, to solve problems, to rightly discern right from wrong. An electronic screen cannot give a child an inquiring mind that seeks after answers that are truth by mediating with questions and helping them think through the answers. An electronic screen cannot train the heart of a child and draw him into a closer relationship with Christ.
Riley Balikian’s Reflections on Curiosity and Wisdom writes:
Indeed, curiosity is simply a response to God’s creative movements. Curiosity does not spring from the heart of man, but from the active Spirit of God. “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge,” says Proverbs 1:7. From God all things proceed, including our curiosity. However, as the proverb implies, if it is not carried out for and by the Spirit of the One who created curiosity, it represents a distortion of the intelligence God has given us. This is why the call to wisdom is necessary. Curiosity breeds a myriad of questions, but wisdom leads us to the prudent ones. Curiosity seeks and explores answers; wisdom is contented by them. Curiosity runs down the path of inquiry with imagination and joy, but wisdom directs it into a proper orientation.
How do you mediate your children’s learning to nurture a holy curiosity in them? There are several steps you as your child’s human mediator, can take to help foster a sense of curiosity in your child.
Is your child apathetic or bored? If he answers the question, “What did you learn in school today?” with “I don’t know” or “Nothing”, he IS apathetic and bored and chances are, he didn’t learn anything. Curious people find themselves living with energy and hope; they are eager to learn and obey God and see Him work in their daily lives and in the world. Such curiosity is our loving desire for our children. I hope you, your child’s mediator, take these thoughts to heart.
Have you ever watched a 2-6 year old who has access to the remote control or a touch screen? He changes channels or quickly flips through programs without engaging in the current screen – seemingly he is bored and is looking for “something” he is interested in that will engage him. (My husband exhibits the same qualities when he uses the TV remote!) But, in actuality, the child is learning to not focus and to only pay attention to what he deems as important; this eventually translates to boredom in learning and a hyperactive mind.
According to Klemm, a professor of neuroscience at Texas A&M University, early on “the brain starts learning how to switch rapidly from one task to another to another. It becomes a habit. But this habit conflicts with focused attentiveness.” As screen time distractions become normal, the brain starts to desire and even require it when it doesn’t exist. Researchers at Florida State University found it only takes one notification on your phone to weaken your ability to focus on a task. Even when such notifications are short, “they can prompt task-irrelevant thoughts, or mind wandering.” Recent research indicates that the risk of attention problems in children and young adults can double when too much time is spent using electronic.
In Twinge and Campbell’s study of the health and well-being of users of various ages and levels of screen time use, evidence showed a negative correlation between the ability to complete a task and screen time at different age levels. The graph to the right depicts the result of the study relating to unfinished tasks. One finding was that high users between the ages of 14-17 were 66% more likely to not complete a task they started.
Finishing a task is closely related to the ability to focus (attention span) and the amount of time on task. The ability to focus includes the ability to concentrate without distraction and to engage the mind. From an educational perspective, time on task, which is considered to be one of the most important factors affecting student learning and achievement, is defined as the amount of time a student spends in quality learning.
From a biblical perspective, several fundamental skills for living are present when you are able to complete a task. As you scan through these qualities, think about which characteristics you desire you and your children to exhibit.
Table 1: Skills related to completing a task
Column A: Skills required to complete a task | Column B: Skills lacking so tasks aren’t completed |
Intrinsically motivated | Extrinsically motivated |
Future or no gratification | Instant gratification |
Organized | Chaotic |
Persistence | Indecisiveness |
Analytical | Illogical |
Goal-oriented | Impulsive |
Self-disciplined | Self-indulgent |
Effective time management | Inefficient use of time |
Focus | Mind wandering, Easily distracted |
Decisive | Wavering |
Plans | Improvises |
Communicates thoughts/ideas | Conceals thoughts/ideas |
Patient | Frustrated |
Strong work ethic | Lazy |
Other empirical evidence shows that our growing obsessions on video screens and their constantly varying images and messages are producing skills that inhibit task completion (column B in Table 1). Although younger brains can process information faster than previous generations, and are better conditioned for constant switching, the research is revealing distinct conclusions that negate these perceived advantages – the ability to focus and learn due to the constant distractions is creating brains that have less ability to focus and learn short attention spans. Could this be what is happening with many of our children today?
Think about how much stimulation you’re exposed to daily, and how much it impacts your world. Between smartphones, iPods, email, TV, DVRs, the internet, social media and more, our brain’s neurons are firing on all cylinders all day long. Our children are experiencing the same stimulation at a time in their lives when, developmentally, they should be learning how to organize information and pay attention. A child who is seen as “having difficulty focusing” or “bright, but not working to his full potential” may be unable to keep up with the demands of a stimulus-filled environment.
A child who is seen as “having difficulty focusing” or “bright, but not working to his full potential” may be unable to keep up with the demands of a stimulus-filled environment.
Naturally, a parent should be concerned if a child is struggling in school. If your child seems to be having trouble focusing or finishing simple tasks without getting distracted, you may be wondering if it’s because of a mental health condition, such as attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Before jumping to conclusions, take some time to survey your child’s environment. Today’s world is vastly different from the one we grew up in. Both parents and clinicians may be “barking up the wrong tree.” That is, they’re trying to treat what looks like a textbook case of mental disorder, but failing to rule out and address the most common environmental cause of such symptoms—everyday use of electronics.
According to Harvard professor DeGutis, “Focusing on a single complex task improves your ability to focus on other tasks.” With this in mind, I have compiled a list of ideas from various websites and educational resources that can help you and your children learn to focus so you can develop relevant skills needed to finish tasks.
Paul says (Philippians 3:14): “I press on toward the goal for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus.” If we do not teach our children to complete simple tasks because they lose focus or are not disciplined enough to complete a simple task, how can we or our children finish the race God has set? Can your child complete a focus on simple tasks? Does he have a short attention span? Is he easily distracted? Does he require continual stimulation? Does he carry through on following directions? If the answers are “yes” to any of these questions, give heed to the use of electronic media before you jump to the wrong solutions to the problem.
You are invited to comment below. I would love to hear your “story” and about how you encourage your child to focus and develop the skills it takes to complete a task.
Next time I will discuss the emotional effects of too much screen time.
Infants and toddlers who frequently use electronic devices do not learn about things of the soul – what makes them who they are: beings created in God’s Image.
When my five kids were growing up, we took long car trips half-way across the US, especially on holidays . . . There were no electronic devices that drew their attention away from our times talking and interacting with one another. So what did we do in the car? We sang, discussed and read books, played games, and talked about life-events. Of course, the kids fought some too, but that entertained an opportunity for important life-lessons. Bottom line: We TALKED TO AND INTERACTED WITH EACH OTHER!
Fast-forward to today – some of my grand-kids sit in the car with their noses and eyes (and minds) fixed on a screen watching a movie, playing games (even educational ones), texting, etc. When my grand-kids get into the car to go to a store or school only 15 minutes away, they are interacting with their electronic device. They rarely RELATE TO EACH OTHER!
Have we forgotten that we were created for human interaction with God and others? Dealing with others:
Because the roots of the relational aspect of humanity are neglected in our current culture, I personally applaud the World Health Organization’s newest recommendations (April, 2019) that children between the ages of 2 to 5 years should watch only one hour or less per day of approved programming and there should be no screen time for infants and toddlers. Although WHO’s intentions were based on the physical well-being of our children, their mental, emotional, and spiritual well-being are at stake with the overuse of electronics.
Reasons for such seemingly drastic measures are expressed in an article written prior to the WHO’s recommendation – Smartphones and Tablets Causing Mental Health Issues in Children as Young as Two. The article (which does not refer to specific research findings) suggests that young children who are entertained by electronic devices are “less curious, less able to finish tasks, less emotionally stable and lowering their self-control.” Each of these negative results can be explained from a biblical mediated learning perspective. For years psychologists have been warning people that such consequences should be expected in our electronic dependent society.
Although the World Health Organization’s intentions are based on the physical well-being of our children, their mental, emotional, and spiritual well-being are at stake with the overuse of electronics.
Whether one agrees or disagrees with such findings, the fact is electronics have become many children’s parent. When using an electronic device, the young child is quiet, behaving, seemingly engaged. However, an electronic device cannot ask the child questions that help him think about wrong answers or expound on right answers, help the child take notice of what is important to know, love the child, model and discuss a relationship with God and others, or develop character in a child. From birth to adult-hood, children need a human mediator – a knowledgeable intercessor/teacher, albeit the parent or instructor – who negotiates between the stimulus (experience) and the individual child thus helping the learner make sense of the world around him, not just his own world. In the Bible, parents are admonished to help their children grow up with knowledge and abilities to focus on God and others, to cope with life, to develop Christ-likeness, and to think biblically.
In future blogs, I will address from a biblical worldview five negative areas that screen time effects a child’s life: curiosity, focus, emotions, self-control, and self-esteem. I will also make suggestions that help you mediate your child’s learning as well as tips on how to eliminate their electronic addiction and/or mediate their learning experience when using electronics.
For more information on mediated learning click HERE.
You are invited to comment below with stories of your child’s experiences with electronics, questions about mediated learning, and/or ideas on this subject.